Quite a good day of Apparatus Finals. Pommels the most exciting. Bars too.
BIG controversy was FIG WTC wrongly devaluing Ellie Black’s Vault. There are several problems in the current Code with why and how they made that error. FIX them.
An even bigger issue came up the next day. In the final rotation of the All Around final in Rotterdam, Joe Fraser competed Floor and accidentally left out a non-value, relatively unimportant corner move. By the rules this should have been a 0.3 deduction. IF judges had taken that, Daniel Marinov would have been Bronze instead of Joe.
It can’t be changed. NOBODY noticed at the time. Judges are to blame, not athletes.
I had no idea Simone was coming. Uchimura surprised me on his arrival, as well.
Big Story
For me the biggest story at World Rotterdam was the Netherlands government denying visas to eligible gymnasts, including the defending World Champion. That won’t happen in China next year, I’m sure. But future World Championships host need to get some guarantee from their governments it won’t happen again.
Kaylia, Claire, and Skye were the names most often listed as favourites
IF Kaylia stayed on Beam and Bars, she’d most like win. Especially if she competed Yurchenko Double Twist again.
first rotation, Kaylia took off for Vault with her feet partly on the foam safety collar βΒ deciding at the instant not to twist. The correct decision. With credit only for Layout Yurchenko, it seemed her chances at a medal were gone. 1.666 lower than qualification. Better than a mat would be to simply increase the size of the Spring Board.
Claire had been quite consistent on Beam this season βΒ but fell on Layout in Acro Series. Half the gymnasts fell on Beam, a disappointment.
Liudmila Roshchina finishing 2nd shouldn’t have been a surprise. She been one of the top Russians for a few years now. BUT just 3 days before the official start date of the competition, Roshchina’s visa was approved but those of Melnikova, Listunova, and Kalmykova denied.
In fact, despite the years denied international competition, Russia is just as strong as before in Men’s and Women’s Gymnastics. For the record, I support banning them so long as murdering dictator-for-life Putin continues his invasion of Ukraine.
Elena Colas continues to impress. It’s just a matter of time before she’s on an AA podium.
Despite the fall on Beam, I don’t think Flavia’s ever looked better.
Fujitsu video analysis has coaches worried that skills credited in the past will suddenly be downgraded. I want computer video analysis integrated into the score as soon as possible. It’s really helped Trampoline.
Nobody watching Skye’s Beam worried that she wasn’t getting credit for her Switch Half and series. Credit to the judges, by exacting evaluation of the rules, it wasn’t rotated far enough. The best way to solve this problem would be to devalue Switch Half.
Roshchina missed her Dance Combo requirement on Beam. Didn’t seem to have a back-up planned for later in the routine.
Manila fell on Beam dismount. Impossible. I’m blocking that from my memory.
China finally winning Gold was my highlight. I recall ALL the World Championships in the past where China won the Men’s Team β and the women were 4th. This time the ladies are Gold medalists on the flight home.
Japan so happy with the Bronze podium finish β fantastic.
Fujitsu Awards go to the Women’s Team of Japan, first team medal in 60 years. And the Men’s Team of host Netherlands.
Newcomer Coralie DEMERS (from Gymnix, Canada) swings like a dream on Bars.
Lia-Monica Fontaine from Canada is now age-17. Her 2nd World Championships. A future all-around star with tremendous potential on Floor and Vault.
Elena Colas, age 16, is already an AA podium contender. Imagine a scenario where she and Kaylia Nemour were both competing for France. … What could have been.
Pease has the best controlled Wolf turn on Beam. WTC should devalue those.
Rebeca back at Worlds. Wonderful for Brazil and everyone.
Claire Pease was terrific, scoring a competition high 56.099 if there was an AA during Team
Without Simone, there’s much more parity in the Team competition. In an exciting 3-up, 3-count Final, many more nations have a chance to medal. For Japan it’s been 60 years since their last podium finish.
Floor scores made more sense than in the qualification round. I’m still convinced that choreography was best ever in 2026. Nations like China and USA much more entertaining.
As a Canadian, I was pleased Ellie Black’s team qualified for the Final. Recall they qualified 8th four years ago, finishing 3rd in Team, qualifying to the Paris Olympics. That didn’t happen this year due to BEAM. (3 falls in qualifying, 2 falls in Team) But this might be Canada’s strongest team ever βΒ when they stay on the skinny Floor.
Automatic qualification as teams to Olympics 2028 for the top three.
1. China β 165.764 2. USA β 165.531 3. Japan β 164.064
USA had a fall on Floor. China hit 12 / 12.
There was a controversial decision on Beam. Skye Blakely didn’t get credit for switch half due to insufficient twist. Lost 0.4 for the D part. AND lost combination requirement for the series for 0.5. She had a back-up series but didn’t do it, thinking the first one was fine.
I feel it’s good for the sport to have a new Team Champion. More competition = more excitement. Also, how soon can Shilese Jones get back. π
It was an excellent and exciting Team Final this year.
Beam was the make or break apparatus, as always.
France β 161.130
Brazil β 159.730
WG2 Russia β 159.394
Italy β 158.129
Canada β 158.096
Fujitsu Awards went to the Women’s Team of Japan, first team medal in 60 years. And the Men’s Team of host Netherlands.
1 Reese Esponda USA 13.633 2 Lia Redick CAN 13.433 3 Abigail Martin GBR 13.433 4 Lia Monica Fontaine CAN 13.366 5 Claire Pease USA 13.333 7 MaΓ―ana Prat FRA 13.300 8 Alice Kinsella GBR 13.266 9 Lyudmila Roshchina RUS 13.266