The “twisties” phenomenon is real.
I’ve experienced it myself and have had several national team gymnasts who have gone through it as well.
I see two dangers:
(1) over medicalizing/psychologizing the issue and (2) giving an invisible symptom as a fairly easy excuse to avoid training and competing.
Medicalizing/psychologizing: this phenomenon is not a “mental health” problem. This is a problem of spatial orientation.
Unfortunately, we know too little about human spatial orientation to be very definitive.
I tried studying spatial orientation while at Utah because of this issue and the use of the term “blacking-out” to describe the same thing that too often occurs on the trampoline.
Unfortunately, a sport-oriented problem like this does not get funding.
While a magnified stress response may be a partial cause, I can tell you that you don’t have to be highly stressed to experience it.
Physicians studying trampoline injuries found that the majority of serious injuries occurred among highly trained athletes and dead-center in the middle of the bed (i.e., they didn’t fall off). The physicians indicated that they thought the trampolinist “blacked out.” However, there is no real loss of consciousness, just orientation.
Moreover, it can be scary as hell when it happens.
Spatial orientation while twisting and somersaulting can be a serious challenge to the integration of the vestibular apparatus, vision, and kinesthesis.
For example: if you stand upright and take your right arm, bend the elbow 90 degrees so that the hand is in front of you, and hold one finger so that it points upward; then rotate your hand in a largish horizontal circle keeping the finger pointing upward. Let’s say you decided to rotate the hand so that it makes a counterclockwise circle as you view it from above (looking down at the circle), if you keep the hand circling counterclockwise while you simultaneously raise your arm/hand so that it circles above your head you will note that the hand is now turning in a clockwise direction. Your brain knows the difference between clockwise and counterclockwise rotation, and you can probably picture that the somersaulting gymnast spins a twist in one direction while going from “right-side-up” to “upside-down” during a somersault. Combining the two orientations results in motor control problems like you experience when trying to rub you stomach and pat your head.
Blindfolded athletes can tell which direction they’re spinning (twisting) while standing upright. However, sometimes they have trouble telling such directions when they are inverted suddenly.
Obviously, a gymnast must pass from an upright body orientation to an inverted body orientation sometimes through two or three somersaults while twisting.
Finally, the loss of spatial orientation can be somewhat “sticky” and remain with an athlete from minutes to months.
Here are some references from work I did on spatial orientation:via email
- Allard T. Perception and sport skill. Coaching Science Update: 52-55, 1981.
- Asch SE and Witkin HA. Studies in space orientation: I. Perception of the upright with displaced visual field. J Exp Psychol 38: 325-337, 1948.
- Asch SE and Witkin HA. Studies in space orientation: II. Perception of the upright with displaced visual fields and with body tilted. J Exp Psychol 38: 455-477, 1948.
- Bardy BG and Laurent M. How is body orientation controlled during somersaulting. J Exp Psychol 24: 963-977, 1998.
- Beck GR, Rabinovitch P, and Brown AC. Acceleration forces at eye level experienced with rotation on the horizontal bar. J Appl Physiol 46: 1119-1121, 1979.
- Berthoz A, Israel I, Georges-Francois P, Grasso R, and Tsuzuku T. Spatial memory of body linear displacement: What is being stored? Science 269(5220): 95-98, 1995.
- Berthoz A, Pavard B, and Young LR. Perception of linear horizontal self-motion induced by peripheral vision (linearvection): Basic characteristics and visual-vestibular interactions. Exp Brain Res 23: 471-489, 1975.
- Botkin M. Gymnasts aid NASA in research of space-age problem. USA Gymnastics July/August: 15-19, 1985.
- Bringoux L, Marin L, Nougier V, Barraud P-A, and Raphel C. Effects of gymnastics expertise on perception of body orientation in the pitch dimension. J Vestib Res 10: 251-258, 2000.
- Campbell PA. What has space experience taught us about disorientation, in: Lecturs in Aerospace Medicine. Brooks Air Force Base, TX: USAF School of Aerospace Medicine Division, 1967, pp 139-149.
- Courjon JH, Clement G, and Schmid R. The influence of interstimulus interval on the development of vestibular habituation to repeated velocity steps. Exp Brain Res 59: 10-15, 1985.
- Cratty BJ. Perception, in: Encyclopedia of sport sciences and medicine. LA Larson, ed. New York, NY: MacMillan, 1971, pp 998-999.
- Croix G, Chollet D, and Thouvarecq R. Effect of expertise level on the perceptual characteristics of gymnasts. J Strength Cond Res 24: 1458-1463, 2010.
- Danion F, Boyadjian A, and Marin L. Control of locomotion in expert gymnasts in the absence of vision. J Sports Sci 18: 809-814, 2000.
- Davlin CD, Sands WA, and Shultz BB. Peripheral vision and back tuck somersaults. Perceptual and Motor Skills 93: 465-471, 2001.
- Davlin CD, Sands WA, and Shultz BB. The role of vision in control of orientation in a back tuck somersault. Motor Control 3: 337-346, 2001.
- Davlin CD, Sands WA, and Shultz BB. Do gymnasts “spot” during a back tuck somersault. International Sports Journal 8: 72-79, 2004.
- Debu B and Woollacott M. Effects of gymnastics training on postural responses to stance perturbations. Journal of motor behavior 20: 273-300, 1988.
- Dichgans J, Held R, Young LR, and Brandt T. Moving visual scenes influence the apparent direction of gravity. Science 178: 1217-1219, 1972.
- Dukalsky VV and Dukalsky AV. Use of a phonogoniometer and tilting device to teach diving. Yessis Review of Soviet Physical Education and Sports 12: 94-97, 1977.
- Gabriel JL. Additional spatial orientation references for competitive diving., 1989.
- Graybiel A and Clark B. Perception of the horizontal or vertical with head upright, on the side, and inverted under static conditions, and during exposure to centripetal force. Aerosp Med 33: 147-155, 1962.
- Graybiel A and Kellogg RS. Inversion illusion in parabolic flight: Its probable dependence on otolith function. Aerosp Med 38: 1099-1102, 1967.
- Grigg P. Peripheral neural mechanisms in proprioception. J Sport Rehab 3: 2-17, 1994.
- Guillot A and Collet C. Field dependence-independence in complex motor skills. Perceptual Motor Skills 96: 575-583, 2004.
- Hartmann M, Haller K, Moser I, Hossner EJ, and Mast FW. Direction detection thresholds of passive self-motion in artistic gymnasts. Exp Brain Res 232: 1249-1258, 2014.
- Hauw D and Durand M. Situated analysis of elite trampolinists’ problems in competition using retrospective interviews. Journal of Sports Science 25: 173-183, 2007.
- Heinen T. Evidence for the spotting hypothesis in gymnasts. Motor Control 15: 267-284, 2011.
- Heinen T, Jeraj D, Vinken PM, and Velentzas K. Rotational preference in gymnastics. Journal of human kinetics 33: 33-43, 2012.
- Henn V. Habituation and plasticity of the vestibulo-ocular reflex. Acta Oto-Rhino-Laryngology 30: 1-8, 1983.
- Hubel DH, ed. Eye, brain, and vision. New York, NY: Scientific American Library, 1988.
- Ivanenko YG, R., Israel I, and Berthoz A. Spatial orientation in humans: perception of angular whole body displacements in two dimensional trajectories. Exp Brain Res 117: 419-427, 1997.
- Ivanenko YP, Grasso R, Israel I, and Berthoz A. The contribution of otoliths and semicircular canals to the perception of two-dimensional passive whole-body motion in humans. J Physiol 502.1: 223-233, 1997.
- Jaslow H. Human tilt perception in a dynamic environment. Aviat Space Environ Med 50: 594-608, 1979.
- King Hogue M. Body awareness and spatial orientation, in: US Diving Safety Manual. JL Gabriel, ed. Indianapolis, IN: U.S. Diving Publications, 1990, pp 97-103.
- Krejcova H, Jer bek J, Bojar M, Tutzk E, Cerny R, and Polechov P. Influence of sports load on the vestibular apparatus, in: The Vestibular System: Neurophysiologic and Clinical Research. MD Graham, JL Kemink, eds. New York, NY: Raven Press, 1987, pp 133-139.
- Krug J, von Lassberg C, and Muehlbauer T. Load effects of fast longitudinal rotations, in: Scientific Proceedings of the XXth International Symposium on Biomechanics in Sports. KE Gianikellis, ed. Caceres, Spain: Universidad de Extremadura, International Society of Biomechanics in Sports, 2002, pp 535-538.
- Lee DN, Young DS, and Rewt D. How do somersaulters land on their feet? J Exp Psychol Hum Percept Perform 18: 1195-1202, 1992.
- Legge GE, Gage R, Baek Y, and Bochsler TM. Indoor Spatial Updating with Reduced Visual Information. PLoS One 11: e0150708, 2016.
- Luis M and Tremblay L. Visual feedback use during a back tuck somersault: evidence for optimal visual feedback utilization. Motor Control 12: 210-218, 2008.
- Malcolm R and Melvill Jones G. A quantitative study of vestibular adaptation in humans. Acta Otolaryngologica 70: 126-135, 1970.
- Malcolm R and Melvill Jones G. Erroneous perception of vertical motion by humans seated in the upright position. Acta Otolaryngologica 77: 274-283, 1974.
- McCormick JH. The relationship between position sense and beginning diving ability. Indiana University, 1970, p P.E.D.
- Nobel CE. The perception of the vertical: III. The visual vertical as a function of centrifugal and gravitational forces. J Exp Psychol 39: 839-850, 1949.
- Nyborg H. A method for analyzing performance in the rod-and-frame test. I. Scand J Psychol 15: 119-123, 1974.
- R‚zette D and Amblard B. Orientation versus motion visual cues to control sensorimotor skills in some acrobatic leaps. Human movement science 4: 297-306, 1985.
- Sanders RH. Head stabilization in forward twisting somersaults, in: Biomechanics in Sports XII. A Barabas, G Fabian, eds. Budapest, Hungary: International Society of Biomechanics in Sports, ITC Plantin, 1995, pp 245-248.
- Sands WA. Science puts the spin on somersaulting. RIP 2: 18-20, 1991.
- Sands WA. Spatial orientation while somersaulting. Technique 11: 16-19, 1991.
- Sands WA. On the training of youth. Technique 13: 35-36, 1993.
- Sands WA. Skill learning and performance – physiological aspects, in: USA Diving Coach Development Reference Manual. RM Malina, JL Gabriel, eds. Indianapolis, IN: USA Diving, 2007, pp 105-114.
- Schone H, ed. Spatial orientation. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1984.
- Witkin HA and Asch SE. Studies in space orientation: III. Perception of the upright in the absence of a visual field. J Exp Psychol 38: 762-782, 1948.
- Witkin HA and Asch SE. Studies in space orientation: IV. Further experiments on perception of the upright with displaced visual fields. J Exp Psychol 38: 762-782, 1948.
- Zhang D, Yu L, and Yue D. Characteristics of vestibular-ocular reflex in elite women gymnasts in China. Sports Science 7: 45-49, 1987.
2. As for the malingering problem, I’m not sure where to go.
I definitely don’t have any magic fixes. However, too often I’ve found that when these symptoms arise, the athlete’s anxiety can certainly be blamed, but much of the anxiety comes from poor preparation.
I suspect that if athletes are prepared “better” there would be fewer such problems. Moreover, I’d like to encourage coaches to investigate the problem thoroughly before jumping to the idea that the athlete is lazy or unmotivated.
William A Sands, Ph.D., FACSM