how to be an FIG judge

It’s Easy to be an Execution judge:

Click PLAY or watch it on YouTube.

“Name” gymnast perfect routine = 9.1 maximum
… miss 2 handstands, deduct 0.2
… miss landing, deduct 0.1
Final E score = 8.80

See the actual score. (PDF)

There’s no need for the Execution judge to actually read the Code of Points. 🙂

The Execution scores are “boxed” so closely together, it’s easy to predict the E score without actually judging. A sad state of affairs.

(via Full Twist)

Read what Valentina Rodionenko had to say about the judges in the AA competition, when the decision didn’t go their way.

jumps out of tumbling

It’s official. Lauren Mitchell is in the Floor final later today, defending her title from 2010. Diana Bulimar from Romania has withdrawn.

She (and all the Australians) take maximum advantage of the oddity that evolved when FIG decided to disallow women to step back out of tumbling passes — a leap, jump or random flutter kick out after landing.

Click PLAY or watch her routine on YouTube.

Lauren does those jumps as correctly as anyone else.

Jumps to disguise lack of control on landings have been used by male gymnasts for decades, but the trend is quite new for girls. It’s smart to use the rules to maximize your score. Especially if you gain bonus for connection.

Personally I don’t mind the jumps. But the old “lunge backwards” was better. Requiring a two foot “stick” would look good — but result in more landing injuries. And we have too many of those now.

Many disagree. Leave a comment if you are one of them.

van Gelder on Rings

… One of the saddest stories of the 2011 World Championships is that of the former World Rings champion from Netherlands:

• Yuri van Gelder was centre of a drug scandal last Worlds in Rotterdam

• he was recently “cleared” to qualify for Olympics

• his routine was good enough to finish on the podium, qualifying him directly (I believe) to London where he could very well win an Olympic medal

Click PLAY or watch his Finals Ring routine on YouTube.

• for some reason he took out his “safe” double layout, replacing it with a piked double front (FALL) … Olympic dream ended.

• and, for some reason, … he decided to wear a Dutch orange outfit for finals, including orange socks. The first orange socks in Worlds history, I would imagine.

drama at Gymnastics Worlds

OK — the women’s all-around competition was a close decision. The ladies of the International Gymnastics Federation scored it this way:

1. Wieber 59.382
2. Komova 59.349
3. Yao 58.598

All 3 medalists had significant “errors”.

Though the final ranking was a surprise at the time, it’s clear that Komova and Wieber should have been very close in final score. It could have gone either way. Either gymnast could have “won” Worlds … if they’d not made mistakes.

source unknown

Jordyn Wieber is World Champion.

Too much is being made of this drama. All three gymnasts (and many other rivals) will soon be back in their gyms training for the Olympics. Psychologically, it’s tough to be world champion going into the Olympics — though Jordyn can handle that challenge better than Vika, I reckon.

The Russian media has jumped all over this, claiming some American conspiracy. … If Vika had won, Americans would be claiming that chief judge Nellie Kim manipulated the final Floor score. (Nellie can’t win, either way.)

Nobody I know has faith that the current rules, and current judges, are capable of accurately differentiating two close performances.

I agree with Brigid – The All-Around: Enough Already.

Let’s move on … to Apparatus Finals.

Today Rodionenko looked a lot happier talking to media. His girls had finished 1st and 2nd on Bars. The AA drama, I hope, has passed.

World Floor Champion – Uchimura

We were taken by surprise when Kohei upgraded his normal routine, busting out the very rare triple twisting double back for Finals.

Click PLAY or watch it on YouTube. (His routine starts at 1min 45sec)

The Difficulty judges may have been taken by surprise, too. An appeal raised his difficulty score up to 6.7 for the win.

As great is the great Kohei, Floor is to me his least appealing apparatus. There’s not much there in terms of connections.

World Champion – Chen Yibing

… ah, we’ve seen this already.

Let’s instead watch the Silver medal routine – Arthur NABARRETE ZANETTI of Brazil. Only 0.2 behind Chen Yibing.

Click PLAY or watch it on YouTube.

Here’s Chen Yibing’s Gold medal routine. (VIDEO)

World Champion – Krisztian BERKI

The defending World Champion watched his major competitors miss. Then put down his usual excellent routine.

Click PLAY or watch it on YouTube.

Vika KOMOVA – World Champion

Click PLAY or watch it on YouTube.

Click through to YouTube to watch the rest of the Bar final, segments linked on the chinesegym1 YouTube channel.

Nabieva finished 2nd, but had an even stronger routine, I thought.

1.Victoria Komova (RUS) 15.500 (6.7)
2.Tatiana Nabieva (RUS) 15.000 (6.6)
3.Huang Qiushuang (CHN) 14.833 (6.7)
4.Jordyn Wieber (USA) 14.500 (6.3)
5.Asuka Teramoto (JPN) 14.200 (6.3)
5.Gabrielle Douglas (USA) 14.200 (6.2)
7.Koko Tsurumi (JPN) 14.066 (6.4)
8.Youna Duforunet (FRA) 12.641 (6.3)

McKayla Maroney – World Champion

Click PLAY or watch it on YouTube.

Watch the entire final.

1.McKayla Maroney (USA) 15.300
2.Oksana Chusovitina (GER) 14.733
3,Thi Ha Thanh Phan (VIE) 14.666
4.Jade Barbosa (BRA) 14.566
6.Giula Steingruber (GER) 14.450
5.Tatiana Nabieva (RUS) 14.349
7.Alexa Moreno (MEX) 14.216
8.Yamilet Peña (DOM) 6.950

who qualified to Olympics?

Confusion aplenty in Tokyo.

THE ALL AROUND is trying to interpret the new FIG regulations.

So far — it looks like — 

MAG teams: JPN – USA – CHN – GER – RUS – KOR – ROU – UKR

MAG Floor: 3.Diego Hypólito (BRA) + Alexander Shatilov (ISR)
MAG PH: 2.Cyril Tommasone (FRA)
… Kristian Berki (HUN) gold winner and Louis Smith (GBR) Bronze don’t reach criteria.
MAG Rings: 2.Arthur Zanetti (BRA)

Confusing. … And what happens if Brazil qualifies a men’s team at the test meet?

WAG teams: USA – RUS – CHN – ROU – JPN – AUS – GER – GBR
3.Phan (VIE) qualified

This is the best guess of Albert Minguillón i Colomer. We’ll wait on Stoica and Kim to tell us officially. Media has not heard a word from either one, so far, in Tokyo.

Related – TAA – More than medals on the line in Tokyo finals