Will Graves calls it a “first-world gymnastics problem”:
“… only two gymnasts per country can advance. It’s designed to spread the wealth and prevent a medal stand sweep. … “
I like the rule which was put in place by FIG.
The mission of the International Olympic Committee is to promote Olympic values in all member nations. Values like ethics, fair play, coach education, non-violence, peace amongst nations, equality of women, anti-doping, safety and the development of sport for all. Sport for all in all member nations.
Determining the BEST athletes is a means to achieve those mandates. Not the only goal.
If you don’t like the Olympic Charter, don’t watch the Olympics. Don’t watch Worlds. Watch the American, Russian and Chinese championships instead. Simple. That way you can see most of the best gymnasts of the world compete AA.
Personally, I love one chance a year to see gymnasts representing smaller nations.
related – Gymternet – More of Our Favorite Small Program Heroes
Gymnastics Coaching.com 