Having coached girls in both systems, I find the American model far superior.
Not perfect. But better than the overly-complex, too frequently-revised Canadian judging regulations.
The biggest advantage of the American system is that more girls can get into competitions in the U.S.A. — the entry levels far more welcoming.
Every grandmother of every child understands the scoring and advancement process.
Here are the Level 5 girls from just one medium sized club. We would never have so many girls of this ability level competing in Canada.
Click PLAY or watch Funtastics Level 5 girls team on YouTube.
Only 4 Canadians competed in this competition of 1500+ athletes. It’s very difficult to train Canadian routines, then travel to the States for competition under American rules. I wish Canada would adopt the American system.
Gymnastics Coaching.com 