A sore point for many is Shannon Miller’s tag line, “most decorated American gymnast“.
Is that still true?
By my count Nastia Liukin and Shannon Miller are tied in World Championships medals at nine.
They are tied in most medals at a single Olympics at five.
Combined Shannon has 16 medals, Nastia 14.
Have I got that right?
Shannon Miller to me had the more impressive career, overcoming more challenges. She’s a double Olympian. Her post-Olympic career has been just as amazing. Shannon’s a wonderful role model to all young gymnasts. She give back to the gymnastics community.
But Nastia is not finished yet. I predict she has more World Championships medals to come.
In the end, history will remember Olympic Champions more grandly than World Champions. Not all medals are equal.
Some argue that statistical comparisons like this are meaningless. The eras were different. The rules different. You may rank one or the other as the greatest ever. The rest is merely decoration.

official website – Shannon Miller
official website – Nastia Liukin
UPDATE: shergymrag points out that Nastia might have qualified for the 2004 Olympics, as well, if not for the changed FIG age requirement. She was too young to go to Athens.







