Many have been linking to an excellent Balance Beam Situation commentary:
Over the years, we’ve all seen any number of hilarious scores showered upon US gymnasts at domestic competitions, and this storied history of ridiculing hyper-American judging has cultivated the widespread assumption that less biased international judges would never succumb to such silliness.
At times in the past, this has been the case, but in the last few years, the international judges have seemed willing to evaluate the execution of routines with that we would normally consider an American lens. …
… “she’ll never receive those scores internationally” needs to be tempered as a credo because it lately amounts to only a tenth or two of difference for most gymnasts rather than a dramatic break that blows up potential scoring and because it is far from consistent, even among the various chosen ones. It has been quite person-specific. …
If you click through you’ll see the statistics are not at all rock solid.
Yet I feel the same way. The best American gymnasts in the past looked GREAT at home, … but not nearly so good once compared directly with the top Chinese, Romanians and Russians. Scores tended to drop.
(It’s still that way with the American men. Uncle Tim, please compare ACTUAL scores on Rings and Pommels for team USA at Worlds 2013 with the scores they got at U.S. Championships 2013.)
Now that the American women are in reality the #1 team, that’s no longer the case.
“To be safe, I think they should just bring the Olympics back to its Greek roots, where nothing gay ever happened.” – Stephen reacts to the Russian Olympic Games
Leyva, who is recovering from a shoulder injury and has not been able to fully train, stated in his withdrawal letter,
“I very much appreciate the opportunity to be, once again, part of the team that will go onto the world stage and represent the United States in the great sport that is gymnastics. Unfortunately, I have to decline. … We have decided that the right decision for me, to better help the team in the future, is to retract from this competition so that I can heal further and reach my full potential yet again.” …
This UTRS list is less comprehensive than the WAG as some of the top guys have not competed much since the London Olympics.
Best Scores this year:
1. Kohei Uchimura Japan 91.850 Japanese Nationals
2. Sam Mikulak USA (91.650) U.S. Nationals
3. Max Whitlock Great Britain 90.650 British Championships 4. Alex Naddour USA (90.600) U.S. Nationals
5. Oleg Verniaiev Ukraine 90.500 University Games
6. John Orozco USA (90.400) U.S. Nationals
7. Ryohei Kato Japan 90.250 University Games
8. Oleg Stepko Ukraine 90.050 University Games
9. Nikolai Kuksenkov Russia 89.950 University Games
10. Fabian Hambuechen Germany 89.850 University Games
Naddour really did have a great day 2 at Championships. I’m surprised to see him ranked above those other guys. Good PH and Rings really help the AA score.
Floor
1. Jake Dalton USA (16.100) U.S. Nationals
2. Shirai Kenzo Japan 15.900 All-Japan Championships
2. Steven Legendre USA (15.900) U.S. Nationals
4. Kohei Uchimura Japan 15.800 NHK Cup
4. Eddie Penev USA (15.800) U.S. Nationals
4. Paul Ruggeri USA (15.800) U.S. Nationals
Pommel
1. Max Whitlock Great Britain 15.967 English Championships
2. Krisztian Berki Hungary 15.966 French International
3. Daniel Keatings Great Britain 15.800 British Championships
3. Zhang Hongtao* China 15.800 Chinese Nationals
5. Luke Stannard USA (15.700) U.S. Nationals
6. Matvei Petrov Russia 15.675 Russian Championships
Rings
1. Eleftherios Petrounias Greece 16.150 Cottbus
2. Arthur Zanetti Brazil 15.900 University Games
3. Denis Ablyazin Russia 15.875 Russian Nationals
4. Yan Mingyong China 15.767 Chinese Nationals
5. Liu Yang China 15.750 Cottbus
5. Brandon Wynn USA (15.750) U.S. Nationals
Vault
1. Yang Hak Seo South Korea 15.787 University Games
2. Ri Se Gwang North Korea 15.550 Doha
3. Denis Ablyazin Russia 15.408 Europeans
4. Manrique Larduet Cuba 15.400 Pan Ams
5. Igor Radivilov Ukraine 15.300 University Games
6. Jake Dalton USA 15.187 Cottbus
P Bars
1. Oleg Stepko* Ukraine 16.050 University Games
2. Oleg Verniaiev Ukraine 16.000 University Games
3. Zhou Shixiong China 15.967 Chinese Nationals
4. Emin Garibov Russia 15.875 University Games
5. Vasileios Tsolakidis Greece 15.800 French International
6. Anton Fokin Uzbekistan 15.750 Anadia
H Bar
1. Koji Uematsu Japan 16.050 All-Japan Championships
2. Emin Garibov Russia 16.025 University Games
3. Kohei Uchimura Japan 15.900 Japanese Nationals
4. Danell Leyva USA (15.850) U.S. Qualifier
5. Yusuke Tanaka Japan 15.800 Japanese Nationals
6. Sam Mikulak USA (15.750) U.S. Nationals
… our awesome video team who literally brought you every moment of this week’s P&G Gymnastics Championships. Check out their hard work on our YouTube channel.
The men’s U.S. World team is Jake Dalton, Sam Mikulak, Danell Leyva, Alex Naddour, Brandon Wynn & Steven Legendre. Congrats, guys! Alternates: John Orozco, Eddie Penev, Paul Ruggeri.
Note that they’ve named six. That means Marta will name six. I assumed wrong. It’s 4 women, 6 men maximum / nation for Worlds 2013.
All pundits agree that Sam Mikulak should focus on the AA. He has a good chance at a medal.
Does a 2nd American have a chance in the AA?
It’s possible. Not many named Leyva and Marcel Nguyen as medal winners for London. Any of the guys who can score 60+ on a good day MIGHT find themselves on the podium below Uchimura. Dalton should train the AA.
Leyva is not looking good right now. I hope he cuts back to training only 2-3 apparatus for Antwerp. He has a shot on P Bars & H Bar. Two Americans might qualify for the H Bar Final. UPDATE – Leyva withdrew to heal his injuries, get back on track for Rio.
On his best day I don’t think Naddour can qualify to the Pommel Final. That competition is going to be stacked with super experienced Pommel specialists.
Rings? Wynn or even Naddour might squeak into the Final. No Low chance for a medal.
Orozco’s not been training long enough since the ACL surgery to be his best for the AA. Like Leyva, he could focus on just his best Finals chances. I’d be quick to call John in if any of the named Team is struggling.
That leaves Floor and Vault. Honestly, it’s Legendre who has the difficulty to have a chance. And he’s looking very good right now. Unfortunately Steve has never rarely been able to land all that difficulty. Don’t bet the mortgage that he’ll stick in Belgium.
Dalton looked even better than Ruggeri on Floor today. Either could qualify for the Floor final. They are two of the most Artistic FX guys in the world.
Some of the team will try to upgrade difficulty IF they qualify to a Final. It’s never easy to win a medal at Worlds in Men’s Gymnastics.
Unlike the American women’s scores, I’m not sure the USA Men are going to score as high in Antwerp as they did in Hartford for the same routines. There’s a small stick bonus in the USA too.
As usual, the Men’s World Championships will be much less predictable than WAG.