Andy Thornton on USA not sending any WAG to the Olympic Test Event:
… The Russian women’s delegation has summoned two “Anastasias” to this competition for these very reasons. First-year senior Olympic hopefuls Anastasia Grishina and Anastasia Sidorova are both expected to challenge for spots on this summer’s Russian Olympic team, but both will do so without any world championship experience because they just became eligible for senior competition on January 1st. The solution? Throw them into January’s Olympic Test Event in the very city in which the Olympic Games will be held, on a podium, alongside numerous Olympic-caliber gymnasts fighting for Olympic berths, and in front of international judges – and see how they handle it. Worse case scenario: they flounder a bit but gain tremendous experience. Best case scenario: they win medals at the competition and boost their reputations and confidence prior to the Olympic season. …
… I was quite surprised to see Marta not take advantage of this huge opportunity for gymnasts like Kyla Ross and Sarah Finnegan. Ross in particular is fully capable of representing the USA in London this summer and will no doubt be right in the Olympic mix. There’s no question, though, that her lack of experience and the risk that comes with throwing a first year senior into the Olympic Games will become a part of the discussion. …
Marta normally wants assurance that new National Team members will “score well” with international judges.
I couldn’t agree more. It was a big mistake for USA to opt out of the meet this time around.
I was freaked out by a Freakonomics audiocast recently.
STEPHEN J. DUBNER:
You know the bromide: “a winner never quits, and a quitter never wins.”
To which Freakonomics Radio says … Are you sure? Sometimes quitting is strategic, and sometimes it can be your best possible plan.
… To help us understand quitting, we look at a couple of key economic concepts in this episode: sunk cost and opportunity cost.
Sunk cost is about the past – it’s the time or money or sweat equity you’ve put into a job or relationship or a project, and which makes quitting hard.
Opportunity cost is about the future. It means that for every hour or dollar you spend on one thing, you’re giving up the opportunity to spend that hour or dollar on something else – something that might make your life better. …
Athletes — they use baseball players in their research — often stay in the sport too long.
In our context we’ve seen over and over again how much more successful gymnasts are when they move to other acrobatic sports. A friend today told me about his daughter — she quit gym and 3 months later was at the National Diving Championships.
… Don’t let your kids quit too soon. But equally important, help them transition at the optimum time. Artistic Gymnastics is still a youth sport, especially for women.
Briley Casanova is a 2 time National Team Member, a future Michigan gymnast and a member of WOGA’s elite team. Briley trains with Laurent Landi’s group at the WOGA Plano …
7:45 or 8:00-11:45 AM- “We do team conditioning after we warm up until about 9:00, then normally my coaches split up our team into 2 groups and 1 group goes to bars and 1 group goes to beam …
3:30-6:30 PM- “Afternoon practice. We usually repeat bars and beam and finish things we might not have finished in the morning. We also try to finish at least one more event that night, either tumbling or vault.”
I’m sure that’s a simplification, but it’s still interesting to see so much emphasis on just 2 of the 4 apparatus.
… With lofty goals comes the need for a more detailed training plan. Time constraints placed on most coaches, and the need for efficiency when dealing with the masses rather than a few select individuals, dictates that meticulous periodization IS NOT reasonable for all levels of gymnastics.
Would it be effective to hone a periodization plan for each athlete? Absolutely.
It’s now been over 2yrs since the death of adult recreational gymnast Michelle Maitland who hit her head on concrete at Townsville Gymnastics. Nothing can bring her back. But this report — released the day before what would have been Michelle’s birthday — might help prevent future catastrophic injury.
My friend Mike Outramsurvived after hitting his head on concrete.
Surely the very first thing coaches must do in any facility is make sure it’s impossible to hit concrete or steel. Long term, we need modify all foam pits to suspended systems, the best being the Jim Walker design.
Here are the 9 recommendations:
1. Gymnastics Australia should review the level of training, assistance and monitoring provided to clubs to implement the Club 10 program. This review should include the methods of monitoring compliance with, and implementation of, the program.
2. Workplace Health and Safety Queensland, Sport and Recreation Services and Gymnastics Queensland should research how to link improved safety outcomes in the sport of gymnastics with the funding and non-financial support provided by SRS.
3. Gymnastics Australia should review their GA lesson plan template, in consultation with its members, with the view to developing a lesson plan template that includes coach positioning and key safety controls. Consideration should be given to sample lesson plans for each apparatus and level.
4. Gymnastics Australia should conduct a training needs analysis and ensure that access to coach accreditation and professional development courses is available.
5. Gymnastics Australia should research and develop methods to assist gymnastics clubs to conduct risk assessments, specifically in the use of gymnastics apparatus.
6. Gymnastics Australia should review the Club 10 equipment maintenance policies and procedures with a view to achieving greater compliance with Club 10 documenting processes.
7. Gymnastics Australia should research and develop methods to assist gymnastics clubs in managing the risk of manual task injuries in gymnastics coaches.
8. Gymnastics Australia should review coach knowledge on spotting and provide additional guidance and training where required.
9. Gymnastics Australia should research the viability of a simple method to document skill progression of gymnasts, including any injuries suffered. This may vary for high level, competitive gymnasts and low level or recreational gymnasts.
This report needs be circulated to sports governing bodies worldwide. Leave a comment if you have ideas on how to make that happen. I’ll send it to some FIG committee members and Gymnastics Canada.
Update: As commenters have pointed out, an improvement to this report would be to better specify exactly what parts of the gym need be “padded”. In the past I’ve narrowed it down to pits and trampoline devices. But it should be broader than that.
Of the top coaches in the world, John Geddert shares the most information.
He’s posting details on the plan for Jordyn Wieber leading up to the world championships, including numbers of routines. Very interesting.
The USA does more than any other nation, I would guess. … though far fewer than Marta did in the past.
… The plan was to do 2 days of 2 a day training followed by a short efficient single training session on day three. This is Marta’s normal plan …2-2-1 usually timed for an important day 4 (podium training, competition etc). It was not uncommon for her to really cut back on the expectations and numbers expected during the 2nd training session. Normal numbers were 2-3 competitive vaults, 2-3 bars routines, 3-4 beam routines and a full floor. The evening training expectations were normally 2 bars, 3 beam and floor dance. The next day we could adjust vault requirements as needed and the floor requirements were a dance through with one pass if you wanted to. We chose to keep doing our 3rd tumbling pass (the one she missed in verification) in the dance routines so as to prove that her mistake was simply a fluke. …
Patti Komara offers Week-Long Camp Lesson Plans for Gymnastics. The same plan used at Stars and Stripes Kids Activity Center in Michigan.
List of themes:
-Super Scrapbooking
-Pretty Princess
-Preschool Gymnastics
-Pirates
-Nature’s Discovery
-My Dolly and Me
-Just Being a Kid-Games, Games, Games
-Imagination Station
-Dinosaur Dig
-Cooking
-Cheerleading
-Arts & Crafts Galore
Anyone who claims “There is no such thing as talent” is wrong.
There are some excellent comments on this post, by the way. Ono paraphrases Michael Shermer, Founding Publisher of Skeptic Magazine, in saying that success in a combination of talent, hard work and luck.
Olympic Champion Kyle Shewfelt was not the most talented guy who ever walked into his gym, for example. (That was Bardana.) But he put in plenty more than 10,000hrs, was very talented … and also was the right kind of athlete to win the 2004 Floor title. He happened to have a short back handspring at the exact time it was essential to do 4 tumbling skills in series without going out of bounds. He happened to be an artistic gymnast in a quadrennial when that rewarded.
Good timing.
______ original post from June 30th:
Coach Howard posted the best summary I’ve seen on the theory that many people can become expert at something if they put in 10,000 hours of focused training.
Mas Watanabe reports that of 13 healthy Level 10 gymnasts at the beginning of season, only 2 are “healthy enough right now to train hard without taping or icing and some type of rehabilitation”.
… There are only days left before J.O. Championships.
… The most areas of injuries were from 2 main areas: legs (ankles & knees) and the lower back.
Also, many of the injuries were chronic type injuries, so they could train, but working with some aches and pains. Some injuries require the support of athletic tape or supporter during the training and constant rehabilitation work. …
photo via Gymnastics Alberta
Gymnasts being injured (or not nearly 100%) for their peak meet seems to be more common today, than in the past. Frustrating for both the coach and athlete.
Some kids find themselves in this situation year after year.
Solutions?
Firstly, we should study gyms that don’t have this problem. Two clubs that jump to mind are Geddert’s Twistars and Oakville. Both have a lot of Level 10 and higher gymnasts who actually show up at every meet, and both clubs keep their older kids training. What are they doing right?
Next we should look at the last 5 weeks before the peak meet. The main goal should be to avoid injury. And stay healthy.
Obviously, a taper in volume will help. Decreasing difficulty, if possible, will help. Modifying landings. Safety spotting, especially at team training camps.
It’s as important to be healthy for the Peak meet, as ready.
… Leave a comment if you’ve any other recommendations.